1 answer

On April 2, 1998, Monica and James Johnson, ages 28 and 32 respectively, visit the Kettering...

Question:

On April 2, 1998, Monica and James Johnson, ages 28 and 32 respectively, visit the Kettering Clinic in hopes of determining why they are having such a difficult time conceiving a child. After testing, it is determined that James is afflicted with low sperm motility and it will be very difficult for the couple to conceive naturally. Therefore, Monica and James make the decision to undergo in vitro fertilization.

Monica begins daily hormone injections and then has her eggs removed for fertilization. After waiting and hoping for several weeks after the implantation procedure, Monica discovers that she has not become pregnant. Undeterred, Monica and James decide to try again. They try four more times before they decide that the pressure to have a baby and the up and downs from the hormones have placed to great a strain on their marriage to continue.

James and Monica move into separate residences and get a divorce. At the time of the divorce, there are 10 frozen embryos being stored at the Kettering Clinic that were never used by James and Monica, and these embryos are all but forgotten in the divorce settlement.

On June 24, 2008, Monica marries David, and they have two happy, healthy twin girls. James remarries Jessica, in May of 2009. Unfortunately, James and Jessica experience the same difficulty with James’ sperm that he and Monica experienced, as well as additional complications with Jessica’s ability to produce eggs. The couple is told that it will be next to impossible to conceive naturally, and almost as difficult to conceive using in vitro fertilization. After several failed attempts, James called Monica and asks if he may use the embryos that they have created to allow Jessica to become pregnant. Monica refuses, explaining that she has two happy little girls, and does not want to be the mother to any additional children, especially with a man who is no longer her husband. Additionally, she does not want to have children that she will not have a say in parenting.

James sues Monica for the property rights to the embryos. In his complaint, he contends that he should gain custody of the embryos because he is the person with the most compelling need for them, as he cannot become a father without them.

You are the judge in this case. As a judge, you should consider legal precedent in determining your ruling. In your decision, please discuss the precedent in this case, please include the likely legal arguments presented by both parties, the legal status of the embryos in question, and your ultimate decision on who should obtain custody of the embryos.


Answers

When a couples are together there is no problem with who should gain the custody of embryos but in case of divorcee and when one partner is in need of it and the other partner refusing to give it may be because of break in the relationship and affecting them emotionally. The cases similar to this had precedent like who decides to give life ,nurture and bring a live baby to the earth are the prioritised people to get the embryos which are frozen.

Though this can affect the women Monica very emotionally that she doesn't wish to have a child of her DNA in a broken relationship carried by a stranger (Jessica) with an IVF.This is always acceptable the benefits and the needs of James overweigh the views and thoughts of Monica the court can decide in favour of James to welcome a new life with the help of embryos.Instead of giving the full 10 embryos half can be given to each and can proceed as per their wish and legal rights.

.

Similar Solved Questions

1 answer
Immunology VPLAIN the importance of randomness in the process of generating BCR and TCR. Mustrate your...
immunology VPLAIN the importance of randomness in the process of generating BCR and TCR. Mustrate your points using examples from the in-class V(D)...
1 answer
4. According to government data, the probability that an adult was never in a museum is...
4. According to government data, the probability that an adult was never in a museum is 18%. In a random survey of 15 adults, what is the probability that two or fewer were never in a museum? Round the answer to 4 decimal places. (3pts)...
1 answer
1. (a) Use Euler's identity e¡θ-cos θ + i sin θ to prove that sin θ=-(eiO , 2i (b) Use the identi...
Time series analysis 1. (a) Use Euler's identity e¡θ-cos θ + i sin θ to prove that sin θ=-(eiO , 2i (b) Use the identities above and the formula for the sum of a geometric series to prove that if n is an integer and j E 1,2,... ,n} then TL TL sin-(2Ttj/n)- n/2 so l...
1 answer
Using the graph below, determine the gas that has the lowest molecular mass at STP A)...
Using the graph below, determine the gas that has the lowest molecular mass at STP A) A B) B C) C D) D E) All of the gases have the same density at STP. Of the following gases, ______ will have the greatest rate of effusion at a given temperature. A) NH_3 B) Ar C) CH_4 D) HBr E) HCl...
1 answer
Which of the following measurements does not change when taking relativity in to account: A) Speed...
Which of the following measurements does not change when taking relativity in to account: A) Speed of light. B) Time. C) Energy. D) Distance....
1 answer
Question 2 (4 points) For each of the following transactions, indicate whether it will increase "+",...
Question 2 (4 points) For each of the following transactions, indicate whether it will increase "+", decrease "-" or have no effect "ne" on a company's cash flows. This question is auto-graded, so you must fill in the blanks as instructed, typing only +, - or ne. Failure ...
1 answer
Steps? Calculate the [OHin an aqueous solution that is 0.125 M NH3 and 0.300 M NH4Cl....
steps? Calculate the [OHin an aqueous solution that is 0.125 M NH3 and 0.300 M NH4Cl. The value of Kb for NH3 is 1.8 × 10-5 1. 0.425 M 2. 7.5 x 10-6 M correct 3. 1.8 x 10-5 M 4, 4.3 × 10-5 M 5. 0.125 M Write a Comme...
1 answer
The Crunchy Granola Company is a diversified food company that specializes in all natural foods. The...
The Crunchy Granola Company is a diversified food company that specializes in all natural foods. The company has three operating divisions organized as investment centers. Condensed data taken from the records of the three divisions for the year ended June 30, 20Y7, are as follows: Cereal Divis...
1 answer
A study looked at the consequences of sleep deprivation on a sample of thousands of medical...
A study looked at the consequences of sleep deprivation on a sample of thousands of medical school interns. Some programs offered night-float coverage, the assignment of another physician to take calls for the on-call participant during an overnight shift for a period of time so that the participant...
1 answer
Need B C and D done please please please help!!! 1. You measure the initial rate...
need B C and D done please please please help!!! 1. You measure the initial rate of an enzyme reaction as a function of substrate concentration in the presence and absence of an inhibitor. The following data was obtained: V. (-) Inhibitor (mm/min) (+) Inhibitor (mM/min) 17 [S] (MM) 0.0001 0.0002 0....
1 answer
Ramort Company reports the following cost data for its single product. The company regularly sells 23,200...
Ramort Company reports the following cost data for its single product. The company regularly sells 23,200 units of its product at a price of $84 per unit. If Ramort doubles its production to 46,400 units while sales remain at the current 23,200-unit level, by how much would the company's contrib...
1 answer
How do you write the partial fraction decomposition of the rational expression #(3x+18)/(x^2+5x+4)#?
How do you write the partial fraction decomposition of the rational expression #(3x+18)/(x^2+5x+4)#?...
1 answer
6.(16) Consider the spring-mass system shown, consisting of two unit masses m, and my suspended from...
6.(16) Consider the spring-mass system shown, consisting of two unit masses m, and my suspended from springs with constants k, and ky, respectively. Assuming that there is no damping in the system, the displacement y(t) of the bottom mass m, from its equilibrium positions satisfies the 4-order equat...
1 answer
QUESTION1 Supply Demand Quantity Using the diagram above, if a price ceiling was introduced at Pt...
QUESTION1 Supply Demand Quantity Using the diagram above, if a price ceiling was introduced at Pt then producer surplus would be O VFB O XUGE P*UX...
1 answer
5. The Government of Bambooz has published the following income distribution data. (20 points) Quintile Average...
5. The Government of Bambooz has published the following income distribution data. (20 points) Quintile Average Income, 2,000 4,000 5,400 7,500 14,000 Quintile % GNI 12.2 16.4 22.8 42.5 4 a) Calculate the % share of GNI for each quintile and the cumulative % share of GNI for each cumulative share of...
1 answer
2. Consider the following equilibrium: Mg(OH)2(8) 5 Mg?'(aq) + 2OH(aq) redict the shift in system at equilibrium if...
2. Consider the following equilibrium: Mg(OH)2(8) 5 Mg?'(aq) + 2OH(aq) redict the shift in system at equilibrium if a solution of HCI is added dropwise to the system at equilibrium. Briefly explain. 0. Predict the change in equilibrium if a solution of NaOH is added dropwise to the system at equ...
1 answer
1. Using the MATLAB rltool command (or rlocus and rlocfind), plot the K > 0 root...
1. Using the MATLAB rltool command (or rlocus and rlocfind), plot the K > 0 root locus for What is the value of the largest damping ra- 2+2s+1 s(s120)7,7 -2,12). 1 + KL(s) = 0, where L(s) = tio associated with the pair of complex poles? At which value of K is it achieved? Turn in a printout of yo...